The Gift of Feedback

The Gift of Feedback

Ruth E. Walker.

Feedback from colleague writers can be a tremendous help to developing writers. Or it can put good manuscripts off the rails. How do you know comments received in a writing circle or workshop feedback session are useful?

Remember Ruth’s three basic rules of successful writing feedback:

Respect:           Give it and get it. All feedback is an offered opinion. You are free to take it or leave it.

Encourage:      Never intend to diminish another writer; always offer colleague-to-colleague comments .

Inspire:            Go ahead and take risks with your writing but be prepared to hear what may need a second look.    

Receiving feedback is an art

  • respect an honest opinion by not defending your writing
  • take notes of verbal comments
  • all feedback is opinion; you may not agree but listen anyway (later on, you may realize that the opinion you dismissed is just what you needed to hear)
  • all feedback is useful; see above and remember you are free to accept or gracefully decline offered feedback
  • don’t interrupt; if you need to clarify what is said, make a note and wait for an appropriate spot to ask a question
  • if feedback is offered in a group session, pay attention; others discussing their opinions about your submission can lead you to exciting discoveries and new ideas

Giving feedback in an art

  • respect the risk a writer takes in asking for feedback; not everyone is ready for an intense critique so if you are unsure of how much to offer, ask the writer
  • begin with one positive aspect before offering suggested areas to review
  • avoid “I like” or “I didn’t like” as much as possible: this isn’t about “liking” something, it is about technique, clarity, logic, development of plot, setting, characters, etc.
  • focus on words, phrases, rhythms, etc., that stand out – either in a good way, or in a way that doesn’t work; offer suggestions if you can
  • be specific about interesting words or ideas and material that seems flat/stereotypical
  • be professional; if you are uncomfortable with the subject, and it affects your ability to critique, it is okay to pass on making any comment

~~~

On-demand Workshops

On-demand Workshops

Gather your group. Pick your topic and your date. And we’ll bring Writescape to you.

From beginning writer to seasoned professional, we’ll customize sessions to suit your programming themes and audience needs. Choose from Writescape’s Workshop Catalogue 2016 to help you and your colleagues hone writing craft and develop new skills and techniques.

“I came away with an understanding that will stick with me … great handouts and examples.”

From two-hour evening sessions to week-long programming, you tell us what you need and when you need it. Writescape will supply professional workshop leaders, hands-on exercises and practical handouts, and a creative, supportive atmosphere for an excellent learning experience.writing-828911_960_720

“…a safe place to be vulnerable with my writing and to risk trying something new.”

Writescape facilitators have delivered workshops and presentations across the Greater Toronto Area, as well as Ottawa Region, Durham Region, and Northumberland, Kawartha, Haliburton, Muskoka, Simcoe and Niagara regions, Southwestern Ontario and into the U.S.

startup-594090_1920 (1)Step 1: talk to your group or colleagues about what you need

Step 2: choose your program from our Workshop Catalogue 2016

Step 3: contact:
info@writescape.ca
905-728-7823
leave a comment

We focus on your needs and deliver inspiration, expertise and support. We make it happen.